MLB player prop bets and odds for Aaron James Judge on Tuesday, May 13, 2025, as the New York Yankees take on the Seattle Mariners.

The top contender is Kansas City shortstop Bobby Witt, who finished second to Judge in AL MVP voting last season. Witt has name recognition and a 20-game hitting streak already this season. One of the best pure hitters in the Majors, Witt is always a threat to string together 20 games in which he hits .400 or better.

The Yankees are facing Osvaldo Bido, who allowed 23 hits and 11 earned runs across his three home starts. Right-handers are also hitting .329 versus Bido, which sets up nicely for Judge. Left-handed hitters have a .280 batting average against Yankees starter Will Warren.