West Islip pinch ... and secure East Islip’s 4-1 win over West Islip in a Suffolk League IV win in Islip Terrace. The play also made a winner out of starting pitcher Thomas Costarelli, who ...

When senior lefty Thomas Costarelli is on – East ... walked four and struck out 11 over six shutout innings as East Islip cruised past host Smithtown West, 10-1, to clinch the Suffolk League ...