I had a discontinued Chanel lipstick and limited edition MAC blush replicated. While my custom matches weren’t identical copies of the originals, I was more than happy with what I walked away with.

Frosted lipsticks were all the rage in the 90s. While most have been discontinued, the celeb-loved MAC Lipstick Shine in Angel lives on. It’s a frosty, pale pink that people clawed to get at the ...