From mesh Mary Jane flats to ballet-inspired sneakers, controversial shoe trends seem to pop up every other day. I can’t lie, though, some of these so-called It Girl shoes have left me skeptical ...

Melissa is the OG jelly shoe maker — can’t have a roundup without a pair. Jennifer Lawrence was just seen in New York City in this exact style as well. The queen of jelly shoes meets the queen ...

Shop similar pairs of jelly shoes starting at $17 Nicol Natale ... in New York City wearing a kitten yarn T-shirt, loose blue jeans, and Melissa Possession Sandals in glittery pink.