Allstate offers a variety of car insurance coverage options and has a below-average level of consumer complaints. However, most drivers will find its rates to be higher than average when compared to ...

Esurance offers cheaper car insurance rates. But Allstate has more coverage options and better customer service. Update: As of March 2023, Esurance is no longer selling insurance to new customers.

Scott Nyerges is a former senior editor and content strategist at U.S. News & World Report, where he led coverage of car insurance and other personal insurance lines. He's also served as a managing ...